e33d2868-0d39-4a1b-9758-af4e51b4d4a0-2

The Costs of Poor Employee Engagement

A commonly cited ballpark figure is that companies with low employee engagement can lose $450-$550 billion annually in the U.S. alone. This figure encompasses the combined costs of reduced productivity, increased turnover, absenteeism, and lower customer satisfaction.

To put it in perspective:

  • Productivity Losses: If engagement levels are low, productivity can drop by 20-30%. For a company with $10 million in annual revenue, a 20% decrease in productivity could translate to a loss of up to $2 million.
  • Turnover Costs: Replacing an employee can cost between 50-200% of their annual salary. For an employee with a $60,000 salary, turnover costs could range from $30,000 to $120,000 per employee.

These figures highlight the financial impact that poor employee engagement can have on a business.

In a thriving workplace, employees frequently express their desire for growth, often by asking for promotions or new responsibilities. 

In a thriving workplace, employees frequently express their desire for growth, often by asking for promotions or new responsibilities. If you're not hearing these requests at least once a month, it's a sign that your employee engagement strategy might not be working as well as it should. A lack of interest in advancement can indicate deeper issues, such as low engagement and motivation among employees.

1. Lack of Promotion Requests as a Red Flag When employees are engaged, they are motivated to grow within the company and take on new challenges. The absence of requests for promotions or professional development suggests that employees may not see a future with your organization, or they may feel that their efforts are not recognized and valued. Research shows that disengaged employees are less likely to seek out new opportunities within their current workplace because they feel disconnected from the company’s goals and values​(15Five).

2. Signs of Disengagement Disengagement can manifest in several ways, such as decreased productivity, lack of enthusiasm, and minimal participation in team activities. According to Gallup, engaged employees are actively involved and enthusiastic about their work, while disengaged employees are emotionally disconnected from their workplace and are less likely to put in extra effort to help achieve organizational goals​(15Five). Additionally, companies where employees do not feel challenged or supported in their roles often see lower engagement levels​(15Five).

3. The Importance of an Engaged Workforce

An engaged workforce is crucial for maintaining high levels of productivity and morale. Engaged employees are more likely to be innovative, offer creative solutions, and contribute to a positive workplace culture. If promotion requests are rare, it may be time to evaluate your engagement strategy. Are you offering clear paths for career advancement? Do employees feel that their achievements are recognized and rewarded?

4. Addressing the Engagement Gap

To improve engagement, focus on creating a culture where employees feel valued and see opportunities for growth. This could include regular check-ins, offering professional development opportunities, and ensuring that employees' contributions are acknowledged. Open communication and feedback are also essential in understanding what employees need to feel more connected and motivated.

Conclusion:

If you’re not hearing employees ask for promotions, it’s a sign that something might be wrong with your engagement strategy. Take the time to understand your employees' needs, provide opportunities for growth, and ensure that they feel valued and recognized. A well-engaged workforce is the key to a successful and dynamic organization. By fostering a culture that encourages growth and recognizes achievements, you can create an environment where employees are not just showing up for a paycheck but are genuinely invested in the company’s success. For more insights on employee engagement and how to enhance it in your organization, consider exploring further resources on the topic.

How Often Do Your Employees Ask for Feedback?

Feedback is an essential component of employee engagement. In a workplace where employees are motivated and invested, they actively seek feedback to improve and grow. If employees rarely ask for feedback, it could indicate a lack of engagement or a sense of disconnect from their roles and the organization. A healthy feedback culture is crucial to maintaining a motivated and engaged workforce.

1. The Absence of Feedback Requests as an Engagement Indicator

When employees are genuinely engaged in their work, they want to know how they are performing and what they can do to improve. If employees are not asking for feedback, it might mean they don’t feel their growth is important to the organization, or they believe their efforts are not being noticed. This lack of communication can lead to stagnation, where employees feel stuck in their roles without a clear path for advancement or improvement.

2. The Role of Feedback in Employee Development

Feedback isn’t just about pointing out what an employee is doing wrong; it’s also about acknowledging what they are doing right and encouraging them to keep growing. Engaged employees typically seek regular feedback because they are eager to learn, grow, and contribute more effectively to the team. If there is a lack of requests for feedback, it may suggest that employees do not feel safe or comfortable seeking constructive criticism, which can hinder their development and engagement.

3. Building a Culture of Feedback

To foster a culture where employees regularly seek and give feedback, it’s important to make feedback a part of the daily workflow. Regular check-ins, clear expectations, and an open-door policy can help create an environment where employees feel comfortable asking for and receiving feedback. Leaders should also model this behavior by seeking feedback from their teams, demonstrating that feedback is a valuable tool for growth at all levels.

4. The Impact of Feedback on Engagement and Retention

Feedback plays a crucial role in employee satisfaction and retention. According to research, employees who receive regular feedback feel more connected to their organization and are more likely to stay long-term. Conversely, a lack of feedback can lead to feelings of neglect and disengagement, prompting employees to seek opportunities elsewhere. Ensuring that feedback is constructive, frequent, and two-way can significantly enhance employee engagement and reduce turnover.

Conclusion

If you notice that employees rarely ask for feedback, it might be time to reassess your engagement strategies. Encourage a culture where feedback is seen as a positive, constructive tool for growth rather than just a critique. By promoting regular, meaningful feedback, you can help ensure that employees feel valued, motivated, and committed to their roles and your organization’s success.

Discover Proven Strategies to Ignite Employee Passion and Drive Business Success with Neupauer Business Solutions.

Why employee engagement, retention, and attraction should be your top priority

In today's competitive business landscape, attracting top talent is only half the battle. The real challenge lies in keeping them engaged and retaining them for the long haul. As business owners, HR professionals, and hiring managers your success hinges on mastering the art of employee engagement, retention, and attraction.

  • The Cost of Turnover
  • The Power of Engagement
  • Retention the Key to Stability
  • Attraction: The First Step in the Employee Journey
  • Why Don't Businesses Do Something About It?
At Neupauer Business Solutions, we believe that an engaged employee is a productive employee. We specialize in helping companies like yours ignite passion in their workforce and fuel overall business success

Warning Signs That Your Engagement is Slipping

Do They Have Questions?

Here are some hidden signs that employees may not be understanding their compensation packages and/or benefits, but are hesitant to speak up:

  1. Lack of questions: Employees may not be asking questions about their benefits, not because they understand them, but because they're afraid to appear uninformed.
  2. Unclaimed benefits: Employees may not be taking advantage of benefits, such as flexible spending accounts or employee assistance programs, because they don't understand how to use them.
  3. Confusion about benefits: Employees may be confused about what benefits are available to them, or how to access them, but may not speak up due to fear of looking uninformed.
  4. Avoiding open enrollment: Employees may avoid participating in open enrollment or benefits meetings because they're intimidated by the complexity of the benefits or don't want to appear uninformed.
  5. Not using employee resources: Employees may not be using employee resources, such as HR or benefits administrators, because they're afraid to ask "dumb" questions.
  6. Lack of engagement in benefits discussions: Employees may not be participating in discussions about benefits or may not be providing feedback on benefits because they don't feel confident in their understanding of the benefits.
  7. Not taking advantage of wellness programs: Employees may not be taking advantage of wellness programs, such as gym memberships or health screenings, because they don't understand how to access them or don't feel comfortable asking about them.
  8. Not using employee discounts: Employees may not be taking advantage of employee discounts, such as discounts on company products or services, because they don't understand how to access them or don't feel comfortable asking about them.

The Problem that Business Owners Are Ignoring

Did you know that disengaged employees cost U.S. companies up to $550 billion annually? Don’t let your business be part of that statistic. Discover how you can transform your company culture and significantly boost productivity.

Why are Businesses, Schools and Governments STILL struggling to have engaged personel?

The answer is very simple, actually...They don't believe it's possible.

The struggle that businesses, schools, and governments face in achieving engaged personnel often stems from a fundamental disbelief that true engagement is possible. This disbelief is not just a fleeting thought but a deeply ingrained mindset that can shape organizational culture, policies, and practices.

1. Mindset of Limitation

Many leaders operate with a mindset of limitation, believing that engagement is an elusive or unattainable goal. They see disengagement as a fixed reality, an inevitable byproduct of work environments that can't be changed or influenced. This belief limits their willingness to invest time, resources, and energy into fostering engagement because they see it as a futile effort. They may feel that employee or student engagement is beyond their control or dependent on external factors such as economic conditions, generational traits, or personal motivations.

2. Lack of Understanding of Engagement

Engagement is often misunderstood or oversimplified. Many assume it’s about making people happy or providing superficial perks like free snacks, gym memberships, or occasional team-building events. However, true engagement goes much deeper—it’s about creating an environment where individuals feel valued, heard, and connected to a larger purpose. When organizations fail to understand this, they miss out on the opportunity to cultivate genuine engagement and instead implement shallow initiatives that don’t address the root causes of disengagement.

3. Resistance to Change

Change is difficult, especially when it challenges long-standing practices and beliefs. Many institutions, whether in business, education, or government, are set in their ways. There’s a reluctance to adopt new strategies that require a shift in culture, a reassessment of leadership styles, or an overhaul of communication practices. This resistance is often rooted in fear—fear of the unknown, fear of losing control, or fear of being unable to adapt. Without a belief that engagement is achievable, there’s no incentive to push through these fears and embrace necessary changes.

4. Short-Term Focus

Organizations are often driven by short-term goals and metrics—profit margins, test scores, and quarterly reports—that don’t account for long-term investment in people. Engagement is a long-term strategy that requires patience, consistent effort, and a willingness to view personnel not just as resources but as individuals with unique needs, talents, and aspirations. Without a belief in the possibility of engagement, organizations remain fixated on immediate results and fail to see the long-term benefits of cultivating a motivated, committed workforce or student body.

5. Lack of Role Models and Success Stories

Another reason for this disbelief is the lack of visible examples of success. Organizations might not see clear, relatable examples of where engagement has been successfully fostered, especially in similar contexts. This lack of role models creates a perception that engagement is either a niche outcome, possible only in rarefied environments like tech startups or unique schools, or that it requires extraordinary circumstances or resources they don't have.

6. Underestimating the Power of Leadership and Communication

Engagement starts at the top. When leaders don’t believe engagement is possible, this skepticism trickles down through all levels of an organization. They underestimate the power of authentic leadership and clear, consistent communication in fostering an engaged culture. Leaders who are disengaged or disconnected from their teams inadvertently promote a culture of indifference. In contrast, leaders who believe in the potential for engagement and actively work towards it inspire others to do the same, creating a ripple effect throughout the organization.

7. Over-Reliance on Data and Metrics

In many institutions, there is an over-reliance on data and metrics to measure success. While these are important, they often do not capture the intangible aspects of engagement—like trust, camaraderie, and emotional investment. When organizations focus solely on what can be easily measured, they may miss out on the broader picture of what truly drives people to be engaged. This over-reliance on data creates a narrow view of success and reinforces the belief that engagement is not achievable because it’s not quantifiable in the same way as other performance metrics.

8. Failure to Address Underlying Issues

Finally, many organizations fail to address the underlying issues that lead to disengagement, such as lack of recognition, poor communication, and inadequate support for professional growth. Instead of tackling these issues head-on, they may opt for quick fixes that do not address the root causes. This failure perpetuates the cycle of disengagement and reinforces the belief that achieving high levels of engagement is impossible.

Conclusion

To overcome these challenges, organizations must shift their mindset and begin to see engagement as a possible and essential component of their success. This requires a commitment to understanding the true nature of engagement, investing in long-term strategies, and fostering a culture where every individual feels valued and motivated. When organizations start to believe in the potential for engagement, they can begin to take the steps necessary to achieve it, breaking free from the limiting beliefs that have held them back.

To fix the issue of disengaged personnel, whether in businesses, schools, or government organizations, you need to shift from a mindset of disbelief to one of possibility and action.

Here’s how to address the root causes of disengagement and foster an environment where people are genuinely engaged:

 

1. Adopt a Growth Mindset

To transform engagement levels, start by cultivating a growth mindset within your organization. This involves recognizing that engagement isn't a fixed trait but something that can be developed and nurtured over time. Leaders need to believe that people can be engaged and that it's worth the effort to make it happen. Promote this mindset at all levels by encouraging continuous learning, embracing challenges, and viewing setbacks as opportunities for growth rather than failures.

How to Implement:

  • Training and Development: Invest in training programs that promote personal and professional growth. Encourage a culture where mistakes are seen as learning opportunities.
  • Leadership Coaching: Provide coaching for leaders to help them understand the impact of a growth mindset and how they can model it to their teams.

2. Clarify and Communicate Purpose

People need to understand the “why” behind their work to feel connected and motivated. Clarifying the organization's mission, vision, and values is crucial, but equally important is consistently communicating these to every level of the organization.

How to Implement:

  • Mission Alignment: Regularly communicate the organization's mission and how each person’s role contributes to it. Use storytelling to make the mission relatable and inspiring.
  • Feedback Loops: Create mechanisms for employees, students, or team members to provide feedback on how their work aligns with the organization’s goals and values. Adjust accordingly to ensure alignment.

3. Foster a Culture of Recognition and Appreciation

Recognition is a powerful motivator. People want to feel valued and appreciated for their contributions. Cultivating a culture where recognition is frequent and meaningful can significantly boost engagement.

How to Implement:

  • Regular Acknowledgment: Implement regular recognition programs that celebrate individual and team achievements. This could be through formal awards, shout-outs in meetings, or even a simple thank-you note.
  • Personalized Recognition: Tailor recognition efforts to the individual. Some people prefer public acknowledgment, while others might appreciate a more private thank-you.

4. Invest in Leadership Development

Engaged organizations have leaders who are not just managers but also coaches, mentors, and advocates for their teams. Developing leaders who are empathetic, communicative, and supportive can transform the engagement levels within an organization.

How to Implement:

  • Leadership Training Programs: Offer programs that focus on emotional intelligence, effective communication, and motivational techniques.
  • Mentorship Programs: Pair emerging leaders with seasoned mentors to help them learn how to engage and inspire their teams effectively.

5. Encourage Open Communication and Transparency

A transparent culture where communication flows freely in all directions is critical for engagement. People need to feel that they are heard and that their opinions matter.

How to Implement:

  • Regular Check-Ins: Implement regular one-on-one meetings between leaders and team members to discuss progress, challenges, and ideas.
  • Anonymous Feedback Channels: Provide anonymous channels for feedback to encourage honesty and transparency, allowing you to address concerns proactively.

6. Align Rewards with Engagement Goals

Ensure that the incentives and rewards within the organization are aligned with the behaviors and outcomes you want to see. If engagement is a priority, then rewards should reflect that.

How to Implement:

  • Performance-Based Rewards: Create reward systems that recognize not just productivity but also collaboration, innovation, and other behaviors that drive engagement.
  • Career Development Opportunities: Offer opportunities for career advancement and personal growth as rewards for sustained engagement.

7. Address Underlying Issues Directly

Many organizations avoid tough conversations about what’s causing disengagement. To foster engagement, you need to be willing to address these issues head-on.

How to Implement:

  • Root Cause Analysis: Conduct surveys, focus groups, or interviews to identify the root causes of disengagement. Look beyond the symptoms to understand the real issues at play.
  • Action Plans: Develop and communicate action plans to address these issues, ensuring that all personnel understand the steps being taken and the role they play in the process.

8. Create a Supportive and Inclusive Environment

A sense of belonging and inclusion is crucial for engagement. When people feel safe and supported, they are more likely to be invested in their work.

How to Implement:

  • Diversity and Inclusion Initiatives: Develop initiatives that promote diversity and inclusion, ensuring everyone feels valued and respected.
  • Wellness Programs: Offer programs that support physical, emotional, and mental well-being, acknowledging that engagement is tied to overall life satisfaction.

9. Demonstrate Commitment from the Top

Engagement efforts need to be championed by the organization’s leadership. When leaders are visibly committed to engagement, it sends a powerful message to everyone in the organization.

How to Implement:

  • Lead by Example: Ensure that senior leaders model the behaviors and attitudes that promote engagement. They should be visible, accessible, and actively involved in engagement initiatives.
  • Communicate Regularly: Leaders should regularly communicate their commitment to engagement, sharing updates, successes, and learning from failures openly.

10. Measure and Adjust

Finally, it’s important to measure engagement regularly and be willing to adjust strategies as needed. Engagement is not a one-time initiative but an ongoing process.

How to Implement:

  • Regular Surveys and Metrics: Use employee engagement surveys, pulse checks, and other tools to measure engagement levels and identify trends.
  • Continuous Improvement: Use the data collected to refine and improve your engagement strategies continually. Be willing to experiment and adapt based on feedback and results.

The answer

By shifting from disbelief to a proactive approach, organizations can create environments where engagement is not only possible but thrives. It requires a combination of leadership, culture, communication, and consistent effort. When organizations believe that engagement is achievable and take deliberate steps to foster it, they unlock the full potential of their people, leading to higher productivity, satisfaction, and overall success.

Attempting to tackle the issue of disengaged personnel alone is a risky and often ineffective approach.

 While the steps to fostering engagement may seem straightforward, implementing them in a meaningful and sustainable way is far from simple. Many organizations underestimate the complexity and commitment required to drive genuine engagement, often leading to superficial efforts that fail to produce lasting results.

 

1. Lack of Expertise and Experience

Engaging personnel isn’t just about implementing a few programs or offering perks—it’s about creating a cultural shift that permeates every level of the organization. This requires deep expertise in understanding what drives engagement and how to cultivate it effectively. Most organizations lack the experience and specialized knowledge needed to navigate these complexities. Without someone who knows the ins and outs of engagement strategies, efforts can quickly become scattered, unfocused, and ultimately ineffective.

2. The Danger of Incomplete Solutions

Organizations that attempt to handle engagement initiatives internally often implement incomplete solutions that don’t address the root causes of disengagement. They might focus on superficial fixes—like one-off events or temporary incentives—that do little to change the underlying culture. This piecemeal approach can not only waste time and resources but also worsen disengagement by creating a sense of insincerity or inconsistency among personnel.

3. The Time and Resource Strain

Trying to boost engagement without external help often places an enormous strain on internal resources. Leaders and HR professionals already have their plates full with daily responsibilities, leaving little time to focus on crafting and executing an effective engagement strategy. The result is often a half-hearted effort that fails to achieve meaningful change. Moreover, the time spent on trial-and-error methods could be better used in core activities that directly contribute to the organization’s goals.

4. Costly Mistakes and Missteps

Attempting to do it alone can lead to costly mistakes. Missteps in understanding what drives engagement or in executing strategies can demoralize staff further, eroding trust and engagement rather than building it. In the long run, these errors can be far more expensive—both financially and culturally—than investing in expert guidance from the start.

5. The Value of an Outside Perspective

Bringing in an expert like us provides an invaluable outside perspective that is often missing when organizations try to handle things internally. We bring a fresh set of eyes and a wealth of experience, offering insights and strategies that may not be immediately apparent to those entrenched in the daily workings of the organization. Our expertise allows for a more objective assessment of what’s working, what isn’t, and what needs to change.

6. Customized Strategies That Don’t Increase Costs

The most significant advantage of working with someone like us is that we offer tailored solutions that fit your organization’s unique needs without increasing costs. Many businesses fear that bringing in external help will be expensive, but our approach is designed to enhance engagement without adding to your budget. we focus on maximizing the resources you already have and finding cost-effective ways to drive engagement, ensuring that any investment you make yields a substantial return.

7. Guaranteed Focus and Commitment

When you partner with someone like us, you get dedicated focus and commitment to engagement—something that’s hard to achieve internally due to competing priorities. We are solely focused on your success and committed to driving the outcomes you desire. This means we can devote the time, energy, and expertise needed to make a real difference, allowing your internal teams to focus on their primary responsibilities.

8. A Proven Track Record

We have a proven track record of driving engagement and achieving results. With experience in transforming organizations and creating environments where personnel are motivated, committed, and fully engaged, we bring a level of confidence and certainty that internal teams simply can’t match. This expertise means that you can trust the process, knowing that every step taken is based on proven methods and real-world success.

9. Sustainable Change, Not Temporary Fixes

My approach is focused on creating sustainable change, not just temporary fixes. We work with you to build a foundation for ongoing engagement, ensuring that the strategies implemented are ingrained into the fabric of your organization. This means you’ll see lasting improvements in engagement, productivity, and morale, rather than short-lived spikes that fade over time.

Next Steps

In conclusion, trying to improve engagement on your own is a risky strategy that often leads to subpar results. Having someone like us, with the expertise and focus needed to drive real change, is the best—and often the only—way to ensure success. We bring the knowledge, experience, and commitment to help your organization achieve its engagement goals without increasing costs. Don’t leave engagement to chance—partner with an expert who can guide you every step of the way and unlock the full potential of your people.